I just started with a new company, and there's been a big debate as to what we should use to backup & restore user data. I recommended USMT or a custom script to get what we want, but many are in favor of Easy Transfer Wizard (ETW).
Truth be told, I never used either (ETW or USMT) at my last company; I wrote a robocopy script to getexactly what we needed which fortunately was really easy because users were good not straying off the beaten path. Now, I'm open to doing the same here, but the not only is culture is completely different, which means data could be anywhere,
the users are furiously adamant, about havingeverything back the way it was. (This goes beyond like Office settings like QAT's, Outlook signatures, nk2, local & remote PSTs that were loaded etc. - the list goes on.)
I feel obligated to encourage us (myself included) to 'get with the times' and use something mainstream. From what I've read USMT is the way to go, and itseems pretty easy to customize. (I'm reading this right now:
http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/dd883247(v=ws.10).aspx - some things still aren't clear.) That said, here's a brief summary of what the last few days of discussions have boiled down to, with ETW leading the pack:
Easy Transfer Wizard
- Easy to use GUI with many options to customize what to migrate
- Has a direct workstation to workstation transfer mode OR backup to network and then import from the destination
- Brings over the core user profile settings and documents, but *NOT* MS office settings/customizations. Would be a cleaner migration and therefore a "fresher" build.
USMT
- Command line utility that would need to be automated to ensure consistency & proper use.
- Can backup to network or external storage needed for user profile storage.
- Migrates MS Office settings & customizations.
- It brings it "all", the good and the bad so issues can migrate from old workstation to new.
Custom Script
- We have total control over what we backup & restore, so its very precise.
- Possible to miss something (although I don't see how that would be different from the above)
- Not pretty - just robocopy in a command window.
What are you all using for backing up & restoring user data?
For you USMT users: Have you all found yourselves making significant customizations to the XMLs?